Antifungal Cream for Athlete’s Foot: What Works (and How to Stop It from Coming Back)

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may earn a commission.

Athlete’s foot is one of the most common — and frustrating — foot conditions, especially for people who struggle with sweaty feet. If your feet stay damp inside shoes or socks, you’re creating the perfect environment for fungal growth. That’s why antifungal creams are often necessary — but they’re only part of the solution.

In this guide, we’ll cover:

• What athlete’s foot really is

• Why sweaty feet make it worse

• When antifungal cream is necessary

• A comparison of the best antifungal creams for athlete’s foot

• How to prevent athlete’s foot from coming back — especially if you sweat a lot

If you’re tired of recurring flare-ups, this article will help you treat the infection and address the underlying cause.

Athlete’s foot (tinea pedis) is a fungal infection that affects the skin of the feet, usually between the toes or on the soles. It’s caused by dermatophyte fungi that thrive in warm, moist environments.

Common symptoms include:

• Itching or burning between the toes

• Peeling, cracking, or flaking skin

• Redness or inflammation

• Foul odor

• Blisters in more severe cases

Athlete’s foot is contagious and often spreads in communal spaces like locker rooms, gyms, pools, and shared showers — but it can also develop simply from trapped sweat in shoes.

Excessive foot sweating creates:

• Constant moisture on the skin

• Softened skin that’s easier for fungus to penetrate

• Shoes that never fully dry

If you deal with hyperhidrosis of the feet, athlete’s foot isn’t just a possibility — it’s a recurring risk.

Even after successful treatment, fungus can return if moisture isn’t controlled. That’s why many people feel like antifungal creams “don’t work,” when in reality, the environment that caused the infection never changed.

Since fungus thrives in damp conditions, reducing sweat with a targeted antiperspirant for sweaty feet can help prevent reinfection.

As shown in the diagram above, excess moisture creates the ideal environment for fungal growth.

Not every foot issue requires antifungal medication.

You likely need antifungal cream if:

• Skin is peeling or cracking

• Itching persists despite keeping feet clean and dry

• Symptoms worsen over several days

• There’s redness between toes that doesn’t improve

You may not need antifungal cream if:

• Odor is the only issue

• Feet feel damp but skin is intact

• No itching, redness, or flaking is present

In those cases, moisture control products like foot powders, antiperspirants, or sock changes may be enough.

Antifungal creams kill or inhibit fungal growth on the skin. Most over-the-counter options use one of these active ingredients:

• Terbinafine – kills fungus quickly and deeply

• Butenafine – similar to terbinafine with long-lasting effects

• Tolnaftate – prevents fungal growth and reinfection

These creams must be applied consistently and for the full treatment duration, even if symptoms improve early.

Stopping treatment too soon is one of the biggest reasons athlete’s foot comes back.

Below is a comparison of three of the most popular and effective OTC antifungal creams — and who each is best for.

Active ingredient: Butenafine hydrochloride
Best for: Fast relief + lingering protection

Pros:

• Clinically proven to continue working after treatment ends

• Typically requires shorter treatment duration

• Strong option for moderate to severe athlete’s foot

Cons:

• Slightly more expensive than some alternatives

• Not ideal for daily preventative use

Who should use it:
If your athlete’s foot keeps coming back — especially due to sweaty feet — Lotrimin Ultra is a strong choice because it keeps working even after visible symptoms improve.

Active ingredient: Terbinafine hydrochloride
Best for: Fastest overall treatment

Pros:

• One of the most effective antifungal ingredients available

• Often clears athlete’s foot in as little as one week

• Widely recommended by doctors

Cons:

• Can be drying for sensitive skin

• Still requires moisture control to prevent recurrence

Who should use it:
If you want the fastest relief and your symptoms are uncomfortable or spreading, Lamisil AT is often the most aggressive OTC option.

Active ingredient: Tolnaftate
Best for: Mild cases & prevention

Pros:

• Affordable and widely available

• Good for preventing reinfection

• Gentler for sensitive skin

Cons:

• Slower than Lamisil or Lotrimin Ultra

• Less effective for severe infections

Who should use it:
Tinactin works well for early-stage athlete’s foot or as a preventative product after stronger treatment has cleared the infection.

Proper application matters just as much as product choice.

1. Wash feet thoroughly with soap and water

2. Dry completely — especially between toes

3. Apply a thin layer of cream

4. Wash hands after application

5. Continue for the full treatment period

Important:
Do not apply antifungal cream to wet or sweaty skin. If your feet sweat heavily, allow time for them to cool and dry first.

Control Foot Sweat

• Use moisture-wicking socks

• Apply foot powder daily

• Rotate shoes to allow drying

Improve Shoe Hygiene

• Let shoes air out fully

• Use shoe deodorizers

• Avoid wearing damp shoes

Maintain Daily Foot Care

• Wash feet daily

• Dry thoroughly

• Inspect for early symptoms

These products work best together, not as substitutes.

• Antifungal cream: Treats active infection

• Foot powder: Controls moisture and prevents recurrence

Once the infection clears, many people transition to daily powder use to stay dry and fungus-free.

Seek medical advice if:

• Symptoms worsen after treatment

• Infection spreads to toenails

• Cracking becomes painful or infected

• You have diabetes or circulation issues

An antifungal cream for athlete’s foot can clear symptoms, but moisture control is what prevents recurrence. If your feet sweat excessively, long-term success depends on addressing that root cause.

By combining:

• Proper antifungal treatment

• Daily moisture control

• Consistent foot hygiene

You can break the cycle of athlete’s foot for good!